| Answering FaithFreedom.org |
| Exposing Ali Sina's Extreme Hate And Foul Mouth - Part II |
Accusation No.12
“A Mentally Deranged”
If Ali Sina wants to say the Holy Prophet (S) is “mentally deranged”, then he needs to tell us if a “mentally deranged” person
can do this:
Sahih Muslim
Book 1, Number 0041:
It is narrated on the authority of Abu Huraira: We were accompanying the Apostle (may peace be upon him) in a march
(towards Tabuk). He (the narrator) said: The provisions with the people were almost depleted. He (the narrator) said: (And the
situation became so critical) that they (the men of the army) decided to slaughter some of their camels. He (the narrator) said:
Upon this Umar said: Messenger of Allah, I wish that you should pool together what has been left out of the provisions with the
people and then invoke (the blessings of) Allah upon it. He (the narrator) said: He (the Holy Prophet) did it accordingly. He
(the narrator) said: The one who had wheat in his possession came there with wheat. He who had dates with him came there
with dates. And Mujahid said: He who possessed stones of dates came there with stones. I (the narrator) said: What did they
do with the date-stones. They said: They (the people) sucked them and then drank water over them. He (the narrator said):
He (the Holy Prophet) invoked the blessings (of Allah) upon them (provisions). He (the narrator) said: (And there
was such a miraculous increase in the stocks) that the people replenished their provisions fully. He (the
narrator) said: At that time he (the Holy Prophet) said: I bear testimony to the fact that there is no god but Allah,
and I am His messenger. The bondsman who would meet Allah without entertaining any doubt about these (two
fundamentals) would enter heaven.
Book 4, Number 1451:
'Imran b. Husain reported: I was with the Apostle of Allah (may peace be upon him) in a journey. We travelled the whole of the
night, and when it was about to dawn, we got down for rest, and were overpowered (by sleep) till the sun shone. Abu Bakr was
the first to awake amongst us. and we did not awake the Apostle of Allah (may peace be upon him) from his sleep allowing him
to wake up (of his own accord). It was 'Umar who then woke up. He stood by the side of the Apostle of Allah (may peace be
upon him) and recited takbir in a loud voice till the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) woke up. When he lifted his
head, he saw that the sun had arisen; he then said: Proceed on. He travelled along with us till the sun shone brightly. He came
down (from his camel) and led us in the morning prayer. A person, however, remained away from the people and did not say,
prayer along with us. After having completed the prayer, the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) said to him: O, so
and so, what prevented you from observing prayer with us? He said: Apostle of Allah! I was not in a state of purity. The
Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) ordered him arid lie performed Tayammum with dust and said prayer. He then
urged me to go ahead immediately along with other riders to find out water, for we felt very thirsty. We were traveling when we
came across a woman who was sitting (on a camel) with her feet hanging over two leathern water bags. We said to her: How
far is water available? She , said: Far, very far, very far. You cannot get water. We (again) said: How much distance is there
between (the residence of) your family and water? She said: It is a day and night journey. We said to her: You go to the
Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him). She said: Who is the Messenger of Allah ? We somehow or the other managed
to bring her to the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) and he asked about her, and she informed him as she had
informed us that she was a widow having orphan children. He ordered that her camel should be made to kneal down
and he gargled in the opening (of her leathern water-bag). The camel was then raised up and we forty thirsty men
drank water till we were completely satiated, and we filled up all leathern water-bags and water-skins that we had
with us and we washed our companions, but we did not make any camel drink, and (the leathern water-bags)
were about to burst (on account of excess of water). He then said: Bring whatever you have with you. So we
collected the bits (of estable things) and dates and packed them up in a bundle, and said to her : Take it away.
This is meant for your children, and know that we have not its any way done any loss to your water.W hen she
came to her family she said: I have met the greatest magician amongst human beings, or he is an apostle, as he
claims to be, and she then narrated what had happened and Allah guided aright those people through that
woman. She affirmed her faith in Islam and so did the people embrace Islam.
Book 19, Number 4392:
This tradition has been narrated on the authority of Salama who said: We fought by the side of the Messenger of Allah (may
peace be upon him) at Hunain. When we encountered the enemy, I advanced and ascended a hillock. A man from the enemy
side turned towards me and I shot him with an arrow. He (ducked and) hid himself from me. I could not understand what he did,
but (all of a sudden) I saw that a group of people appeared from the other hillock. They and the Companions of the Prophet
(may peace be upon him) met in combat, but the Companions of the Prophet turned back and I too turned back defeated. I
had two mantles, one of which I was wrapping round the waist (covering the lower part of my body) and the other I was putting
around my shoulders. My waist-wrapper got loose and I held the two mantles together. (In this downcast condition) I passed by
the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) who was riding on his white mule. He said: The son of Akwa' finds himself to
be utterly perplexed. Where. the Companions gathered round him from all sides. the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon
him) got down from his mule. picked up a handful of dust from the ground, threw it into their (enemy) faces and said: May
these faces be deformed 1 There was no one among the enemy whose eyes were not filled with the dust from this
handful. So they turned back fleeing. and Allah the Exalted and Glorious defeated them, and the Messenger of
Allah (may peace be upon him) distributed their booty among the Muslims.
Book 19, Number 4394:
It has been narrated on the authority of Anas that when (the news of) the advance of Abu Sufyan (at the head of a force)
reached him. the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) held consultations with his Companions. The narrator said:
Abu Bakr spoke (expressing his own views), but he (the Holy Prophet) did not pay heed to him. Then spoke 'Umar (expressing
his views), but he (the Holy Prophet) did not pay heed to him (too). Then Sa'd b. 'Ubada stood up and said: Messenger of
Allah, you want us (to speak). By God in Whose control is my life, if you order us to plunge our horses into the sea, we would
do so. If you order us to goad our horses to the most distant place like Bark al-Ghimad, we would do so. The narrator said:
Now the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) called upon the people (for the encounter). So they set out and
encamped at Badr. (Soon) the water-carriers of the Quraish arrived. Among them was a black slave belonging to Banu al-
Hajjaj. The Companions of the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) caught him and interrogated him about Abu
Sufyan and his companions. He said: I know nothing about Abu Sufyan, but Abu Jahl, Utba, Shaiba and Umayya b. Khalaf are
there. When he said this, they beat him. Then he said: All right, I will tell you about Abu Sufyan. They would stop beating him
and then ask him (again) about Abu Sufyan. He would again say', I know nothing about Abu Sufyan, but Abu Jahl. 'Utba,
Shaiba and Umayya b. Khalaf are there. When he said this, they beat him likewise. The Messenger of Allah (may peace be
upon him) was standing in prayer. When he saw this he finished his prayer and said: By Allah in Whose control is
my life, you beat him when he is telling you the truth, and you let him go when he tells you a lie. The narrator said:
Then the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) said: This is the place where so and so would be killed. He
placed his hand on the earth (saying) here and here; (and) none of them fell away from the place which the
Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) had indicated by placing his hand on the earth.
Book 23, Number 5057:
Jabir b. 'Abdullah reported: When the ditch was dug, I saw Allah's Messenger (may peace he upon him) feeling very hungry. I
came to my wife and said to her: Is there anything with you? I have seen Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) feeling
extremely hungry. She brought out a bag of provisions which contained a sa', of barley. We had also with us a lamb. I
slaughtered it. She ground the flour. She finished (this work) along with me. I cut it into pieces and put it in the earthen pot and
then returned to Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) (for inviting him). She said: Do not humiliate me in the presence of
Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) and those who are with him. When I came to him I whispered to him saying:
Allah's Messenger, we have slaughtered a lamb for you and she has ground a sa' of barley which we had with us. So you
come along with a group of people with you. Thereupon Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) said loudly: O people of
the ditch, Jabir has arranged a feast for you, so (come along). Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: Do not
remove your earthen pot from the hearth and do not bake the bread from the kneaded flour until I come. So I came and Allah's
Messenger (may peace be upon him) came and he was ahead of the people; and I came to my wife and she said (to me): You
will be humbled. I said: I did what you had asked me to do. She (his wife) said: I brought out the kneaded flour and Allah's
Messenger (may peace be upon him) put some saliva of his in that and blessed It. He then put saliva in the earthen pot and
blessed it and then said. Call another baker who can bake with you. and bring out the soup from it, but do not remove it from
the hearth, and the guests were one thousand. (Jabir said): I take an oath by Allah that all of them ate (the food to
their fill) until they left it and went away and our earthen pot was brimming over as before, and so was the case
with our flour, or as Dahhak (another narrator) said: It (the flour) was in the same condition and loaves had been
prepared from that.
Book 23, Number 5059:
Anas b. Malik reported : Abu Talha sent me to Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) in order to invite him (for meal).
She had prepared a meal. So I came and found Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) along with some people. He
looked at me, and I felt shy and said : Accept the invitation of Abu Talha. He (the Holy Prophet) asked the people to get up.
Thereupon Abu Talha said : Allah's Messenger, I have prepared something for you. Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon
him) touched (the food) and invoked blessings upon it, and then said : Let ten persons from my Companions enter (the
house). He then said : Eat, and (in the meanwhile) brought out something from between his fingers for them. They then
began to eat until they had their fill and then went out. He then asked ten more men (to have the meal) and they
ate to their fill, and the ten persons went on getting in (and eating the food) and then getting out until none was
left amongst them who had not got in and eaten to his fill. He then collected (the remaining part of the food) and
it (the quantity of the food) was the same (as it had been prior to the serving of guests).
Book 23, Number 5062:
Anas b. Malik reported this incident pertaining to the feast given by Abu Talha to Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) with
the addition of these words : "Abu Talha stood at the door (to welcome the honourable guest) until Allah's Messenger (may
peacec be upon him) came there, He (Abu Talha) said to him : Allah's Messenger, the thing (we intend to offer you as a meal)
is small in quantity. Thereupon he (the Holy Prophet) said : Bring that, for Allah will soon bless it (and increase it).
Book 30, Number 5662:
Mu'adh b. Jabal reported that he went along with Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) in the expedition of Tabuk and he
(the Holy Prophet) combined the prayers. He offered the noon and afternoon prayers together and the sunset and night
prayers together and on the other day he deferred the prayers; he then came out and offered the noon and afternoon
prayers together. He then went in and (later on) came out and then after that offered the sunset and night prayers together
and then said: God willing, you would reach by tomorrow the fountain of Tabuk and you should not come to that until it is
dawn, and he who amongst you happens to go there should not touch its water until I come. We came to that and two persons
(amongst) us reached that fountain ahead of us. It was a thin flow of water like the shoelace. Allah's Messenger (may peace
be upon him) asked them whether they had touched the water. They said: Yes. Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him)
scolded them, and he said to them what he had to say by the will of God. The people then took water of the fountain in their
palms until it became somewhat significant and Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) washed his hands and his face
too in it, and then, took it again in that (fountain) and there gushed forth abundant water from that fountain, until all
the people drank to their fill. He then said: Mu'adh, it is hoped that if you live long you would see its water irrigating well the
gardens.
Book 5, Number 2333:
Zaid b. Wahb Jahani reported and he was among the squadron which wall under the command of Ali (Allah be pleased with
him) and which set out (to curb the activities) of the Khwarij. 'Ali (Allah be pleased with him) said: 0 people, I heard the
Messeinger of Allah (may peace be upon him) say: There would arise from my Ummah a people who would recite the Qur'an,
and your recital would seem insignificant as compared with their recital, your prayer as compared with their prayer, arid your
fast,as compared with their fast. They would recite the Qur'an thinking that it sup- ports them, whereas it is an evidence
against them. Their prayer does not get beyond their collar bone; they would swerve through Islam just as the arrow passes
through the prey. If the squadron which is to encounter them were to know (what great boon) has been assured to them by
their Apostle (may peace be upon him) they would completely rely upon this deed (alone and cease to do other good deeds),
and their (that of the Khwarij) distinctive mark is that there would be (among them) a person whose wrist would be without the
arm, and the end of his wrist would be fleshy like the nipple of the breast on which there would be white hair. You would be
marching towards Muawiya and the people of Syria and you would leave them behind among your children and your property
(to do harm). By Allah, I believe that these are the people (against whom you have been commanded to fight and get reward)
for they have shed forbidden blood, and raided the animals of the people. So go forth in the name of Allah (to fight against
them). Salama b. Kuhail mentioned that Zaid b. Wahb made me alight at every stage, till we crossed a bridge. 'Abdullah b.
Wahb al-Rasibi was at the head of the Khwarij when we encountered them. He ('Abdullah) said to his army: Throw the spears
and draw out your swords from their sheaths, for I fear that they would attack you as they attacked you on the day of Harura.
They went back and threw their spears and drew out their swords, and people fought against them with spears and they were
killed one after another. Only two persons were killed among the people (among the army led by Hadrat 'Ali) on that day. 'Ali
(Allah be pleased with him) said: Find out from among them (the dead bodies of the Khwarij) (the maimed). They searched but
did not find him. 'Ali (Allah be pleased with him) then himself stood up and (walked) till he came to the people who had been
killed one after another. He ('Ali) said: Search them to the last, and then ('Ali's companions) found him (the dead body of the
maimed) near the earth. He (Hadrat 'Ali) then pronounced Allah-O-Akbar (Allah is the Greatest) and then said, Allah
told the Truth and His Messenger (may peace be upon him) conveyed it. Then there stood before him 'Abida Salmani
who said: Commander of the Believers, by Allah, besides Whom there is no god but He, (tell me) whether you heard this
hadith from the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him). He said: Yes, by Allah, besides Whom there is no god but
He. He asked him to take an oath thrice and he took the oath.
Book 20, Number 4699:
It has been reported on the authority of Anas b. Malik that the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) used to visit Umm
Haram daughter of Milhan (who was the sister of his foster-mother or his father's aunt). She was the wife of 'Ubada b. Samit,
One day the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) paid her a visit. She entertained him with food and then sat down
to rub his head. The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) dozed off and when he woke up (after a while), he was
laughing. She asked: What made you laugh. Messenger of Allah? He said: Some people from my Umma were presented
to me who were fighters in the way of Allah and were sailing in this sea. (Gliding smoothly on the water), they
appeared to be kings or like kings (sitting) on thrones (the narrator has a doubt about the actual expression used by the Holy
Prophet). She said : Messenger of Allah, pray to Allah that He may include me among these warriors. He prayed for her. Then
he placed his head (down) and dozed off (again). He woke up laughing, as before. (She said) I said: Messenger of Allah, what
makes you laugh? He replied: A people from my Umma were presented to me. They were fighters in Allah's way. (He described
them in the same words as he had described the first warriors.) She said: Messenger of Allah, pray to God that He may
include me among these warriors. He said: You are among the first ones.
Umm Haram daughter of Milhan sailed in the aea in the time of Mu'awiya. When she came out of the sea and (was
going to mount a riding animal) she fell down and died.
Book 31, Number 6003:
'A'isha reported that Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) called his daughter Fatima (during his last illness). He said.
to her something secretly and she wept. He again said to her something secretly and she laughed. 'A'isha further reported
that she said to Fatima: What is that which Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) said to you secretly and you wept and
then said to you something secretly and you laughed? Thereupon she said: He informed me secretly of his death and
so I wept. He then again informed me secretly that I would be the first amongst the members of his family to
follow him and so I laughed.
Book 39, Number 6721:
Abdullah said that five signs have (become things) of the past (and have proved the truth of the Holy Prophet) :
(Enveloping) by the smoke, inevitable (punishment to the Meccans at Badr), (the victory of) Rome, (violent)
seizing (of the Meccans at Badr) and (the splitting up of) the Moon.
Secondly, Ali Sina would have to also call the Companions of the Holy Prophet (S), “mentally deranged”, since they witnessed
these acts, and affirmed they happened, and witnessed other important things as well:
Sahih Muslim
Book 30, Number 5713:
Sa'd reported that on the Day of Uhud I saw on the right side of Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) and on his left
side two persons dressed in white clothes and whom I did not see before nor after that, and they were Gabriel
and Michael (Allah be pleased with both of them).
Clearly, a man who was mentally deranged couldn’t perform the acts performed above, nor could he speak such accurate
prophecies! And again, if the Holy Prophet (S) was hallucinating because he said he saw angels, then the Sahaba were also
hallucinating. As shown above, one of the Companions of the Holy Prophet (S) saw Gabriel and Michael on the right side of
the Holy Prophet (S).
Thus, we have refuted Alhumdulilah Ali Sina’s “accusations”. Ali Sina now, as promised before, must remove his site, as his
accusations have been disproved by the Grace of Allah SWT!
May Allah Almighty continue to shower prayers and peace, forever and always, upon the Best of Creation, the Holy Prophet
Muhammad Rasool Allah Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam…………Ameen!
We have ended Part 2, continue on to Part 3.
End Of Part II ...
Previous Accusation (11)
Back to Index
Back to the section of Umar
“A Mentally Deranged”
If Ali Sina wants to say the Holy Prophet (S) is “mentally deranged”, then he needs to tell us if a “mentally deranged” person
can do this:
Sahih Muslim
Book 1, Number 0041:
It is narrated on the authority of Abu Huraira: We were accompanying the Apostle (may peace be upon him) in a march
(towards Tabuk). He (the narrator) said: The provisions with the people were almost depleted. He (the narrator) said: (And the
situation became so critical) that they (the men of the army) decided to slaughter some of their camels. He (the narrator) said:
Upon this Umar said: Messenger of Allah, I wish that you should pool together what has been left out of the provisions with the
people and then invoke (the blessings of) Allah upon it. He (the narrator) said: He (the Holy Prophet) did it accordingly. He
(the narrator) said: The one who had wheat in his possession came there with wheat. He who had dates with him came there
with dates. And Mujahid said: He who possessed stones of dates came there with stones. I (the narrator) said: What did they
do with the date-stones. They said: They (the people) sucked them and then drank water over them. He (the narrator said):
He (the Holy Prophet) invoked the blessings (of Allah) upon them (provisions). He (the narrator) said: (And there
was such a miraculous increase in the stocks) that the people replenished their provisions fully. He (the
narrator) said: At that time he (the Holy Prophet) said: I bear testimony to the fact that there is no god but Allah,
and I am His messenger. The bondsman who would meet Allah without entertaining any doubt about these (two
fundamentals) would enter heaven.
Book 4, Number 1451:
'Imran b. Husain reported: I was with the Apostle of Allah (may peace be upon him) in a journey. We travelled the whole of the
night, and when it was about to dawn, we got down for rest, and were overpowered (by sleep) till the sun shone. Abu Bakr was
the first to awake amongst us. and we did not awake the Apostle of Allah (may peace be upon him) from his sleep allowing him
to wake up (of his own accord). It was 'Umar who then woke up. He stood by the side of the Apostle of Allah (may peace be
upon him) and recited takbir in a loud voice till the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) woke up. When he lifted his
head, he saw that the sun had arisen; he then said: Proceed on. He travelled along with us till the sun shone brightly. He came
down (from his camel) and led us in the morning prayer. A person, however, remained away from the people and did not say,
prayer along with us. After having completed the prayer, the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) said to him: O, so
and so, what prevented you from observing prayer with us? He said: Apostle of Allah! I was not in a state of purity. The
Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) ordered him arid lie performed Tayammum with dust and said prayer. He then
urged me to go ahead immediately along with other riders to find out water, for we felt very thirsty. We were traveling when we
came across a woman who was sitting (on a camel) with her feet hanging over two leathern water bags. We said to her: How
far is water available? She , said: Far, very far, very far. You cannot get water. We (again) said: How much distance is there
between (the residence of) your family and water? She said: It is a day and night journey. We said to her: You go to the
Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him). She said: Who is the Messenger of Allah ? We somehow or the other managed
to bring her to the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) and he asked about her, and she informed him as she had
informed us that she was a widow having orphan children. He ordered that her camel should be made to kneal down
and he gargled in the opening (of her leathern water-bag). The camel was then raised up and we forty thirsty men
drank water till we were completely satiated, and we filled up all leathern water-bags and water-skins that we had
with us and we washed our companions, but we did not make any camel drink, and (the leathern water-bags)
were about to burst (on account of excess of water). He then said: Bring whatever you have with you. So we
collected the bits (of estable things) and dates and packed them up in a bundle, and said to her : Take it away.
This is meant for your children, and know that we have not its any way done any loss to your water.W hen she
came to her family she said: I have met the greatest magician amongst human beings, or he is an apostle, as he
claims to be, and she then narrated what had happened and Allah guided aright those people through that
woman. She affirmed her faith in Islam and so did the people embrace Islam.
Book 19, Number 4392:
This tradition has been narrated on the authority of Salama who said: We fought by the side of the Messenger of Allah (may
peace be upon him) at Hunain. When we encountered the enemy, I advanced and ascended a hillock. A man from the enemy
side turned towards me and I shot him with an arrow. He (ducked and) hid himself from me. I could not understand what he did,
but (all of a sudden) I saw that a group of people appeared from the other hillock. They and the Companions of the Prophet
(may peace be upon him) met in combat, but the Companions of the Prophet turned back and I too turned back defeated. I
had two mantles, one of which I was wrapping round the waist (covering the lower part of my body) and the other I was putting
around my shoulders. My waist-wrapper got loose and I held the two mantles together. (In this downcast condition) I passed by
the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) who was riding on his white mule. He said: The son of Akwa' finds himself to
be utterly perplexed. Where. the Companions gathered round him from all sides. the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon
him) got down from his mule. picked up a handful of dust from the ground, threw it into their (enemy) faces and said: May
these faces be deformed 1 There was no one among the enemy whose eyes were not filled with the dust from this
handful. So they turned back fleeing. and Allah the Exalted and Glorious defeated them, and the Messenger of
Allah (may peace be upon him) distributed their booty among the Muslims.
Book 19, Number 4394:
It has been narrated on the authority of Anas that when (the news of) the advance of Abu Sufyan (at the head of a force)
reached him. the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) held consultations with his Companions. The narrator said:
Abu Bakr spoke (expressing his own views), but he (the Holy Prophet) did not pay heed to him. Then spoke 'Umar (expressing
his views), but he (the Holy Prophet) did not pay heed to him (too). Then Sa'd b. 'Ubada stood up and said: Messenger of
Allah, you want us (to speak). By God in Whose control is my life, if you order us to plunge our horses into the sea, we would
do so. If you order us to goad our horses to the most distant place like Bark al-Ghimad, we would do so. The narrator said:
Now the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) called upon the people (for the encounter). So they set out and
encamped at Badr. (Soon) the water-carriers of the Quraish arrived. Among them was a black slave belonging to Banu al-
Hajjaj. The Companions of the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) caught him and interrogated him about Abu
Sufyan and his companions. He said: I know nothing about Abu Sufyan, but Abu Jahl, Utba, Shaiba and Umayya b. Khalaf are
there. When he said this, they beat him. Then he said: All right, I will tell you about Abu Sufyan. They would stop beating him
and then ask him (again) about Abu Sufyan. He would again say', I know nothing about Abu Sufyan, but Abu Jahl. 'Utba,
Shaiba and Umayya b. Khalaf are there. When he said this, they beat him likewise. The Messenger of Allah (may peace be
upon him) was standing in prayer. When he saw this he finished his prayer and said: By Allah in Whose control is
my life, you beat him when he is telling you the truth, and you let him go when he tells you a lie. The narrator said:
Then the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) said: This is the place where so and so would be killed. He
placed his hand on the earth (saying) here and here; (and) none of them fell away from the place which the
Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) had indicated by placing his hand on the earth.
Book 23, Number 5057:
Jabir b. 'Abdullah reported: When the ditch was dug, I saw Allah's Messenger (may peace he upon him) feeling very hungry. I
came to my wife and said to her: Is there anything with you? I have seen Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) feeling
extremely hungry. She brought out a bag of provisions which contained a sa', of barley. We had also with us a lamb. I
slaughtered it. She ground the flour. She finished (this work) along with me. I cut it into pieces and put it in the earthen pot and
then returned to Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) (for inviting him). She said: Do not humiliate me in the presence of
Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) and those who are with him. When I came to him I whispered to him saying:
Allah's Messenger, we have slaughtered a lamb for you and she has ground a sa' of barley which we had with us. So you
come along with a group of people with you. Thereupon Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) said loudly: O people of
the ditch, Jabir has arranged a feast for you, so (come along). Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: Do not
remove your earthen pot from the hearth and do not bake the bread from the kneaded flour until I come. So I came and Allah's
Messenger (may peace be upon him) came and he was ahead of the people; and I came to my wife and she said (to me): You
will be humbled. I said: I did what you had asked me to do. She (his wife) said: I brought out the kneaded flour and Allah's
Messenger (may peace be upon him) put some saliva of his in that and blessed It. He then put saliva in the earthen pot and
blessed it and then said. Call another baker who can bake with you. and bring out the soup from it, but do not remove it from
the hearth, and the guests were one thousand. (Jabir said): I take an oath by Allah that all of them ate (the food to
their fill) until they left it and went away and our earthen pot was brimming over as before, and so was the case
with our flour, or as Dahhak (another narrator) said: It (the flour) was in the same condition and loaves had been
prepared from that.
Book 23, Number 5059:
Anas b. Malik reported : Abu Talha sent me to Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) in order to invite him (for meal).
She had prepared a meal. So I came and found Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) along with some people. He
looked at me, and I felt shy and said : Accept the invitation of Abu Talha. He (the Holy Prophet) asked the people to get up.
Thereupon Abu Talha said : Allah's Messenger, I have prepared something for you. Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon
him) touched (the food) and invoked blessings upon it, and then said : Let ten persons from my Companions enter (the
house). He then said : Eat, and (in the meanwhile) brought out something from between his fingers for them. They then
began to eat until they had their fill and then went out. He then asked ten more men (to have the meal) and they
ate to their fill, and the ten persons went on getting in (and eating the food) and then getting out until none was
left amongst them who had not got in and eaten to his fill. He then collected (the remaining part of the food) and
it (the quantity of the food) was the same (as it had been prior to the serving of guests).
Book 23, Number 5062:
Anas b. Malik reported this incident pertaining to the feast given by Abu Talha to Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) with
the addition of these words : "Abu Talha stood at the door (to welcome the honourable guest) until Allah's Messenger (may
peacec be upon him) came there, He (Abu Talha) said to him : Allah's Messenger, the thing (we intend to offer you as a meal)
is small in quantity. Thereupon he (the Holy Prophet) said : Bring that, for Allah will soon bless it (and increase it).
Book 30, Number 5662:
Mu'adh b. Jabal reported that he went along with Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) in the expedition of Tabuk and he
(the Holy Prophet) combined the prayers. He offered the noon and afternoon prayers together and the sunset and night
prayers together and on the other day he deferred the prayers; he then came out and offered the noon and afternoon
prayers together. He then went in and (later on) came out and then after that offered the sunset and night prayers together
and then said: God willing, you would reach by tomorrow the fountain of Tabuk and you should not come to that until it is
dawn, and he who amongst you happens to go there should not touch its water until I come. We came to that and two persons
(amongst) us reached that fountain ahead of us. It was a thin flow of water like the shoelace. Allah's Messenger (may peace
be upon him) asked them whether they had touched the water. They said: Yes. Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him)
scolded them, and he said to them what he had to say by the will of God. The people then took water of the fountain in their
palms until it became somewhat significant and Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) washed his hands and his face
too in it, and then, took it again in that (fountain) and there gushed forth abundant water from that fountain, until all
the people drank to their fill. He then said: Mu'adh, it is hoped that if you live long you would see its water irrigating well the
gardens.
Book 5, Number 2333:
Zaid b. Wahb Jahani reported and he was among the squadron which wall under the command of Ali (Allah be pleased with
him) and which set out (to curb the activities) of the Khwarij. 'Ali (Allah be pleased with him) said: 0 people, I heard the
Messeinger of Allah (may peace be upon him) say: There would arise from my Ummah a people who would recite the Qur'an,
and your recital would seem insignificant as compared with their recital, your prayer as compared with their prayer, arid your
fast,as compared with their fast. They would recite the Qur'an thinking that it sup- ports them, whereas it is an evidence
against them. Their prayer does not get beyond their collar bone; they would swerve through Islam just as the arrow passes
through the prey. If the squadron which is to encounter them were to know (what great boon) has been assured to them by
their Apostle (may peace be upon him) they would completely rely upon this deed (alone and cease to do other good deeds),
and their (that of the Khwarij) distinctive mark is that there would be (among them) a person whose wrist would be without the
arm, and the end of his wrist would be fleshy like the nipple of the breast on which there would be white hair. You would be
marching towards Muawiya and the people of Syria and you would leave them behind among your children and your property
(to do harm). By Allah, I believe that these are the people (against whom you have been commanded to fight and get reward)
for they have shed forbidden blood, and raided the animals of the people. So go forth in the name of Allah (to fight against
them). Salama b. Kuhail mentioned that Zaid b. Wahb made me alight at every stage, till we crossed a bridge. 'Abdullah b.
Wahb al-Rasibi was at the head of the Khwarij when we encountered them. He ('Abdullah) said to his army: Throw the spears
and draw out your swords from their sheaths, for I fear that they would attack you as they attacked you on the day of Harura.
They went back and threw their spears and drew out their swords, and people fought against them with spears and they were
killed one after another. Only two persons were killed among the people (among the army led by Hadrat 'Ali) on that day. 'Ali
(Allah be pleased with him) said: Find out from among them (the dead bodies of the Khwarij) (the maimed). They searched but
did not find him. 'Ali (Allah be pleased with him) then himself stood up and (walked) till he came to the people who had been
killed one after another. He ('Ali) said: Search them to the last, and then ('Ali's companions) found him (the dead body of the
maimed) near the earth. He (Hadrat 'Ali) then pronounced Allah-O-Akbar (Allah is the Greatest) and then said, Allah
told the Truth and His Messenger (may peace be upon him) conveyed it. Then there stood before him 'Abida Salmani
who said: Commander of the Believers, by Allah, besides Whom there is no god but He, (tell me) whether you heard this
hadith from the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him). He said: Yes, by Allah, besides Whom there is no god but
He. He asked him to take an oath thrice and he took the oath.
Book 20, Number 4699:
It has been reported on the authority of Anas b. Malik that the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) used to visit Umm
Haram daughter of Milhan (who was the sister of his foster-mother or his father's aunt). She was the wife of 'Ubada b. Samit,
One day the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) paid her a visit. She entertained him with food and then sat down
to rub his head. The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) dozed off and when he woke up (after a while), he was
laughing. She asked: What made you laugh. Messenger of Allah? He said: Some people from my Umma were presented
to me who were fighters in the way of Allah and were sailing in this sea. (Gliding smoothly on the water), they
appeared to be kings or like kings (sitting) on thrones (the narrator has a doubt about the actual expression used by the Holy
Prophet). She said : Messenger of Allah, pray to Allah that He may include me among these warriors. He prayed for her. Then
he placed his head (down) and dozed off (again). He woke up laughing, as before. (She said) I said: Messenger of Allah, what
makes you laugh? He replied: A people from my Umma were presented to me. They were fighters in Allah's way. (He described
them in the same words as he had described the first warriors.) She said: Messenger of Allah, pray to God that He may
include me among these warriors. He said: You are among the first ones.
Umm Haram daughter of Milhan sailed in the aea in the time of Mu'awiya. When she came out of the sea and (was
going to mount a riding animal) she fell down and died.
Book 31, Number 6003:
'A'isha reported that Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) called his daughter Fatima (during his last illness). He said.
to her something secretly and she wept. He again said to her something secretly and she laughed. 'A'isha further reported
that she said to Fatima: What is that which Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) said to you secretly and you wept and
then said to you something secretly and you laughed? Thereupon she said: He informed me secretly of his death and
so I wept. He then again informed me secretly that I would be the first amongst the members of his family to
follow him and so I laughed.
Book 39, Number 6721:
Abdullah said that five signs have (become things) of the past (and have proved the truth of the Holy Prophet) :
(Enveloping) by the smoke, inevitable (punishment to the Meccans at Badr), (the victory of) Rome, (violent)
seizing (of the Meccans at Badr) and (the splitting up of) the Moon.
Secondly, Ali Sina would have to also call the Companions of the Holy Prophet (S), “mentally deranged”, since they witnessed
these acts, and affirmed they happened, and witnessed other important things as well:
Sahih Muslim
Book 30, Number 5713:
Sa'd reported that on the Day of Uhud I saw on the right side of Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) and on his left
side two persons dressed in white clothes and whom I did not see before nor after that, and they were Gabriel
and Michael (Allah be pleased with both of them).
Clearly, a man who was mentally deranged couldn’t perform the acts performed above, nor could he speak such accurate
prophecies! And again, if the Holy Prophet (S) was hallucinating because he said he saw angels, then the Sahaba were also
hallucinating. As shown above, one of the Companions of the Holy Prophet (S) saw Gabriel and Michael on the right side of
the Holy Prophet (S).
Thus, we have refuted Alhumdulilah Ali Sina’s “accusations”. Ali Sina now, as promised before, must remove his site, as his
accusations have been disproved by the Grace of Allah SWT!
May Allah Almighty continue to shower prayers and peace, forever and always, upon the Best of Creation, the Holy Prophet
Muhammad Rasool Allah Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam…………Ameen!
We have ended Part 2, continue on to Part 3.
End Of Part II ...
Previous Accusation (11)
Back to Index
Back to the section of Umar